Wednesday, November 28, 2007

The Vestibule: "Opportunists"

48 comments:

Anonymous said...

"Here sighs and cries and wails coiled and recoiled on the starless air, spilling my soul to tears."

Is Dante saying that he feels bad for the opportunists stuck in the vestibule? I think he feels that their punishment is harsh.

Anonymous said...

"...Sweet Spirit, / what souls are these who run through this black haze?" / And he to me: "These are the nearly soulless / whose lives concluded neither blame nor praise."

Why didn't these people choose a side? Did they simply not care for either side, or were they trying to prevent both from being offended?

Anonymous said...

"Virgil rebukes him saying that this journey for Dante is willed by a higher power (God). Therefore, Charon is powerless to refuse, finally, and takes them across to the first circle."

This proves that in the story, God is still superior, and in hell he can't be ignored.

Anonymous said...

"Here you shall pass among the fallen people, souls who have lost the good of intellect."

What does virgil mean when he says they have lost the good of intellect? I don't really see how intellect would do them any good at the place they are at.

Anonymous said...

Do you think it is rather ironic that the people stuck in the vestibule are called "opportunists?"

The definition of opportunities says that opportunities are favorable or suitable occasions or time.

Anonymous said...

"As they are stung, streams of blood and putrid matter drip to the ground which is eaten by the maggots and worms at their feet."

Why do the maggots and worms eat the blood. Why does the blood not stay to show what is happening to them. To give them more pain of what is acctually happening and how much damage the wasp are causing them?

Anonymous said...

"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught".

If Someone gets in the Vestibule why cant they get out?

Anonymous said...

As the fallen souls chase the Banner, they themselves are pursued by hornets and wasps.

Why are the insects trying to not let them get the flag?

Anonymous said...

Virgil rebukes him saying that this journey for Dante is willed by a higher power (God).

I think that this goes along with our discussion in class about if Dante is saying there is or isn't a God. We missed this when we were reading, but here Virgil is saying that God has a purpose in Dante seeing the depths of Hell. Maybe God God is showing Dante that this is what he and the people of the world go through after they die if they don't know God. God's purpose for showing Dante is to save him.

Anonymous said...

The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught.

What does the banner represent?

Anonymous said...

"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught.
In life, they went after things only to their own benefit."

If they only go after things that benefit them then why are they chasing a banner? What does it symbolize?

Anonymous said...

The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught.

So basically its saying that theres no way out if it can never be caught. So its like a sin that can never be change, cause it cant be caught.

Anonymous said...

"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught."

i wonder what thebanner represent ? does it represent freedom i wonder.

Anonymous said...

"In life, they went after things only to their own benefit, things which were always changing. Just so, the Banner is constantly changing, never stopping. As they go after it, like on a wind, the banner eludes them, just as they lived their lives on winds of change."

The banner is saying there was constant changes that these people followed. Was Dante following these changes? Can he make it through these changes?
-I think that quote is describing the changes of life, and how people follow them but in a bad way and how changes can be mistakes....or mistakes can cause changes.

Anonymous said...

"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught."

It states in the book that the banner represents the item that the vestibule had desired before life. So the Vestibule are forced to chase after the banner because it causes an illusion for the Vestibule to think it is the item that they wanted ?

Anonymous said...

"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught."

It states in the book that the banner represents the item that the vestibule had desired before life. So the Vestibule are forced to chase after the banner because it causes an illusion for the Vestibule to think it is the item that they wanted?

-Jared Mukina

Anonymous said...

"The more they try to run away, the more the insects goad them."
Do you think if they simply stop running they would leave them alone or would they attack even more?

Anonymous said...

Anonomymous, I think you made a good point that the banner could represent something in their lives that they wanted, i never thought of it like that.

Anonymous said...

i feel fruity today

Anonymous said...

"Just as they gave up reason to be caught up in their passions, forever are they caught up in the wind of Hell."

I wonder what passions could be bad enough to be sent to the second ring of hell.

Anonymous said...

Chelsea' asked, "Do you think if they simply stop running they would leave them alone or would they attack even more?"

I think so, but they are probably so delirious with fear that they can't stop running.

Anonymous said...

to Lauryns ?
Do you think it is rather ironic that the people stuck in the vestibule are called "opportunists?"

yes because it makes it seem like they have a choice of if they want to be there or if they want to be sent & be free

Anonymous said...

The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught."

i wonder what thebanner represent ? does it represent freedom i wonder.


A lot of people have used this quote, and to answer Dustin I do think the banner symbolizes freedom. In our lives we constantly want freedom, and in hell to be free isn't an option.

Anonymous said...

Carrie said...
"What does virgil mean when he says they have lost the good of intellect? I don't really see how intellect would do them any good at the place they are at."

I think he means that in life, they did not make the choice between good or evil- Satan or God- so they lost their intellect and that is their punishment.

Anonymous said...

dustin said...
"The souls in the Vestibule continually chase this Wavering Banner which can never be caught."

i wonder what thebanner represent ? does it represent freedom i wonder.

I agree with him i think the banner means freedom but they will never reach it

Anonymous said...

Noelle said..
Why didn't these people choose a side? Did they simply not care for either side, or were they trying to prevent both from being offended?

I sort of agree with Noelle's question on this. I think that people in this section are people that didn't really say there wasn't a God, but didn't have faith in God either. But this is only my opinion. I'm really not sure.

Anonymous said...

Noelle said...
"...Sweet Spirit, / what souls are these who run through this black haze?" / And he to me: "These are the nearly soulless / whose lives concluded neither blame nor praise."

Why didn't these people choose a side? Did they simply not care for either side, or were they trying to prevent both from being offended?

I never thought of it like that but I suppose it is possible that they didn't care for either side. Personally, I think they could have been pagans. They were neutral towards the idea of any religion.

Anonymous said...

elizabeth , you asked :

Is Dante saying that he feels bad for the opportunists stuck in the vestibule? I think he feels that their punishment is harsh.

I think he is saying that he does feel bad for the people he sees and when he looks at them he feels their pain and it makes tears come to his eyes like he wants to cry from seeing them treated that way.

Anonymous said...

"Here you shall pass among the fallen people, souls who have lost the good of intellect."

I wonder if he fears that the souls would grab him a pull him down with him.

Anonymous said...

to what sheena said...

Why do the maggots and worms eat the blood. Why does the blood not stay to show what is happening to them. To give them more pain of what is acctually happening and how much damage the wasp are causing them?


...then the blood would never go away and it would keep building would it not?

Anonymous said...

female use of viagra buy cheap viagra online bad side effects of viagra effect of viagra on women side effects of viagra does watermelon have viagra effect buy viagra online at too much viagra free viagra without prescription cheap cheap viagra viagra strips viagra mexico non prescription viagra viagra patent

Anonymous said...

sihsworldlit.blogspot.com; You saved my day again.

Anonymous said...

Do you have copy writer for so good articles? If so please give me contacts, because this really rocks! :)

Viagra Online said...

" Through me you pass into the city of woe:
Through me you pass into eternal pain:
Through me among the people lost for aye.

Justice the founder of my fabric mov'd:
To rear me was the task of power divine,
Supremest wisdom, and primeval love.

Before me things create were none, save things
Eternal, and eternal I endure.
All hope abandon ye who enter here."
this is the inscription that according to Dante is written over the hell door, the message to all those who want to enter into a real nightmare.
Generic Viagra Buy Viagra.

Anonymous said...

Our ensemble creates a subject new year card on the underpinning of unexcelled and magnificent projects.
These projects are carried out close the cards the first pike of explicit artists and designers in
the shop who are experts in every gist of the word. They are also very flexible, so you can
acquire very engaging dealing easter card designs, depending on the characteristic needs of each client.
We do not own a mistress printing machines undertaking the highest distinction of each individualistic card.
Broad quote of identification b docket allows you to bump into rendezvous with the expectations of even the most urgent customers
from every conceivable industry. We make sure the language and service of huge quantities of responsibility
cards in the shortest possible time. In our holder, the highest attribute is the payment of the proposed
value and trusty checking from people receiving and carrying revealed an order in place of obligation cards.
With access to the services offered through our website, you can quickly and without undue
formalities state an order object of goods, review the commitment and approved it and ordered some charge
cards. On our company as a righteous trade window-card is oft a guaranty fitting for success.
Greet
Merio [url=http://www.kalendarze.dogory.pl]Kalendarze[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hello there,

This is a inquiry for the webmaster/admin here at sihsworldlit.blogspot.com.

May I use some of the information from your post above if I provide a link back to your website?

Thanks,
Peter

Anonymous said...

Adipex is indicated for patients who need help losing weight and whom have not been successful through other means. http://www.secblitz.com/ - adipex online no rx Adipex is a prescription appetite suppressant that is prescribed to the obese to help them lose weight in an ideal amount of time. Adipex is a prescription appetite suppressant that is prescribed to the obese to help them lose weight in an ideal amount of time. Up to 20% off list price! Adipex for sale without prescription!

Anonymous said...

is it illegal to buy xanax online xanax for anxiety and depression - xanax bars mixed with weed

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]casino games[/url] hinder the latest [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com/]casino[/url] autonomous no consign reward at the foremost [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]online casinos
[/url].

Anonymous said...

oZzy moved away ever before, I miss his cock,
and i am always hungry for sexual intercourse.
FUCK MY PUSSY!

my blog post: hcg injections

Anonymous said...

Hi, I lоg on to your blog likе еvеry week.

Your ωriting style is aωesome, κeеp ԁoing what you're doing!

my web page: weight loss supplements

Anonymous said...

I got this web site from my buddy who shared with me regarding
this web page and now this time I am browsing
this website and reading very informative content at this time.


My webpage ... waterproof samsung galaxy s3 case

Anonymous said...

Нi therе, Ӏ enjοy
reading through your aгticle post. ӏ wanted to ωгite a
little сomment to suрρort уou.


Here іs my blοg wp.5punkt1.com

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I enjoy reading through your article post. I wanted
tо write а little сοmment
to support you.

Feel fгee tо surf to my website ... wp.5punkt1.com

Anonymous said...

hello!,Ι really like your writіng νеry
so much! shaгe we be in contaсt mοre about yοur post оn AOL?

I need a specialist in this house to resοlvе my prοblem.

May be that iѕ you! Looking forward to look
you.

Fеel freе to viѕit my web-ѕіte .
.. aluminum iphone 5 case

Anonymous said...

Aѕ the аԁmin of this web рage is working, no uncertainty verу ѕoon it will be well-known, due to
іts qualіty contents.

mу blog - www.bequineapproved.co.uk

Anonymous said...

Another available treatment option that can be done at home without a prescription is a topical ointment.
An individual can develop anywhere from 1 to well over 100 skin tags.
'We usually have two or three people in the room, no-one has time, so we have one person tightening the body and another giving a treatment on the face'.


Feel free to visit my homepage - skin tags pregnancy - -

Anonymous said...

We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
Your site provided us with valuable info to work on. You
have done an impressive job and our whole community will be thankful to you.


my web page :: best allergy medicine